Routes versus cameos
Who you can date in CreepyDates
I keep this page to stop the route list from getting muddy. If the itch page names someone as a route, they get a route guide. If they only show up in a devlog bug note or a comment, they stay here. I am not copying creepypasta lore from a wiki.
On the route list
The developer listing names these six entries. This is a developer report (single source), not an independently tested availability matrix. Each route page separates reported choices from missing steps.
Spoilers: In the story, not on the list
Laughing Jack is named in the chapter 3 developer bug note, but is absent from the route list. Homicidal Liu is also absent from that list; the old glasses-scene source is unavailable, as explained on his status page. His story appearance is not established here.
For Zalgo, the developer mouse-effect reply names him; a separate player report describes impersonating Ben. Those are different scene claims, not two sources verifying the unnamed new-character identity in the chapter 4 devlog. Nina and Clockwork have no sourced route announcement here.
Questions
Who is dateable?
Jeff the Killer, Eyeless Jack, Ben Drowned, Ticci Toby, Masky and Hoodie together, and Slenderman.
Is Laughing Jack dateable?
No. He has a chapter 3 conversation. The devlog mentions him because that conversation crashed the build.
Who is the new chapter 4 character?
The devlog says there is one and does not give a name. Players and an author reply about the mouse point at Zalgo.