From itch.io, not a ranking I made up
Games like CreepyDates
These are selected projects shown on itch.io's related-games page on 28 October 2026, not sequels or a play-tested ranking. The comparison notes describe each project's advertised premise. Read its own warnings, availability, and platform details before choosing; a recommendation placement is not an endorsement by Hahadit.
Titles on that page
Source for placement: itch.io's related-games page (single platform source). The following project links were reachable in the recheck. Their authors' descriptions are developer reports; none of these games has been played for this guide.
- Fear Me [Jeff the Killer's Dating Sim] — a different creator's Jeff-focused suspense/romance visual novel, rather than another CreepyDates chapter.
- HORROR/ROMANCE a slasher dating simulator — an alternative for a slasher-dating premise rather than the CreepyDates cast.
- Date at the Cemetery — advertises a cemetery date with a stranger; a setting-led alternative.
- How to Date an Entity (and stay alive) — a supernatural-dating alternative with its own project and warnings.
- The Freak Circus — advertised as an 18+ yandere visual novel; not a like-for-like age-rating substitute.
- Killer Chat! Original Edition and Expanded Edition [DEMO] — the premise is a writer mistakenly invited to a serial-killer server. The expanded demo is a separate page, not a CreepyDates expansion.
- Bob Velseb the Cannibal the Dating Simulator — another character-specific fan dating project, not a route for this game.
How to choose between them
For another Jeff-focused story, start with Fear Me. For a different horror-romance premise, compare the cemetery, entity, circus, or chat-server projects using their own descriptions and content warnings. This is a premise comparison, not a judgment of writing quality, route depth, or safety. Prices and file sizes are deliberately omitted because they change independently.
Questions
Are these sequels?
No. They are other itch projects that the recommendation page placed next to CreepyDates.
Which one is the Jeff dating sim?
Fear Me, Jeff the Killer's Dating Sim, by neesacomplex, is a different game with its own page.
Where should I download CreepyDates?
Only from hahadit.itch.io/creepydates. The links below are for other titles.