Route guide
Ticci Toby route in CreepyDates
Toby is on Hahadit's six-route list. Players describe choosing him in chapter 1 and finding a knife in Jeff's room, but those reports do not supply a Toby weapon answer, a bottle-scene sequence, or ending requirements. The notes below separate overlapping reports from single-source details.
Spoilers: Chapter 1: player-sourced steps
LiriumValy describes the favorite-character choice and knife; Narciso also says to begin Toby's route in chapter 1. The Fish thread has separate replies by cool guy and XxCookieChanxX about the knife. These are different players, not a developer walkthrough; only overlapping details have corroboration.
- Route start: LiriumValy says to choose Toby as the favorite creepypasta in chapter 1; Narciso agrees that his route must begin there to continue in chapter 2.
- Knife: two replies in the Fish thread place it among Jeff's clothes. This is distinct from choosing a weapon for an ending.
- Toby illustration: XxCookieChanxX alone describes using the knife on the first door on the right beside the pictures. Single source; the other reply describes Masky and Hoodie's door, not Toby's.
- Chapter 2 continuation: those players say the earlier route choice matters. They do not provide an exact save-import or menu-button sequence.
Spoilers: Chapter 4, one report only
NerdyB1443 mentions leaving on a task with Masky, Hoodie, and Toby. This is a single source about that player's sequence, not proof that every Toby save must follow it. The chapter 4 devlog does not provide a Toby-specific walkthrough.
Spoilers: What I could not verify
The Jeff closet report describes a weapon rack and an outdoor meeting with Ben and Eyeless Jack. It does not name a weapon to select, much less one that changes Toby's ending. Bottle-scene choices and ending conditions are unknown in the available written evidence. This page does not substitute an invented answer for either gap. Toby's place on the route list comes from the developer listing (single source).
Video
Chapter 1 video that includes Toby. A later chapter 2 video from 4 December 2025 also follows Toby into the woods.
Questions
Which weapon should I pick for Toby?
I found no comment, devlog, or second write-up that names a weapon for the Toby ending. I am leaving the answer blank.
How do I start his route?
Pick Ticci Toby as your favorite creepypasta in chapter 1. A second comment says chapter 2 continues that choice.
What is the bottle scene?
I could not verify the steps. It is named in short videos, not in a text source I can cite.